elindholm
edited for content
Ok one last try. There is a difference between being wrong or bad at your job and being naive. Naive means being inexperienced or having a lack of knowledge.
I think it can also mean getting outsmarted or having a lack of wisdom.
Front-office moves are about salesmanship. If you go to the car lot and drool over the one you want, forget about getting a good price. Some people have bought a dozen cars and never learned that lesson. That's naive.
I don't think McDonough is especially naive. It seems to me that he's made his fair share of decent moves. But he was exposed in the Bledsoe situation. First he got into a micturition contest with Bledsoe over social media, which made him look petty and devalued the player. Then he made the laughable announcement that he was considering several "tantalizing" offers, or some word like that, which everyone on this board instantly recognized as a bluff. As a result he took an asset of unknown value and put it on a death spiral, so that everyone knew that he'd have to take the first remotely palatable offer he got.
That was naive, in spades. He was ignorant and thoughtless about how his moves were going to play out, and he compounded the error by making a ridiculous claim that he knew what he was doing. He was going to get taken to the cleaners, and the only question was by whom.
At a poker table, the saying is, "If you can't spot the fish in the first five minutes, you're it." In any zero-sum game, experienced competitors are looking for telltale signs that their opposition is in over its head. McDonough might as well have posted a photo of himself with the caption, "I have no idea what I'm doing."
That's naive.