3 TD's from the 1 yard line in 1 game last year?
And if he was the most complete back then why does JJ have more touches and is the main blocking RB after Edge on passing downs. JJ has played in 50% more snaps then Shipp. That doesnt exactly scream most complete backup RB to me.
You must be registered for see images attach
TD7:22
Marcel Shipp 1 Yd Run (Neil Rackers Kick)
Drive: 13 plays, 90 yds, 7:2270
You must be registered for see images attach
FG13:58Jeff Wilkins 27 Yd
Drive: 13 plays, 64 yds, 6:3673SECOND QUARTERARISTL
You must be registered for see images attach
TD9:11Larry Fitzgerald 11 Yd Pass From Matt Leinart (Neil Rackers Kick)
Drive: 4 plays, 50 yds, 2:38143
You must be registered for see images attach
FG14:42Neil Rackers 23 Yd
Drive: 6 plays, 29 yds, 1:33173THIRD QUARTERARISTL
You must be registered for see images attach
TD2:46Torry Holt 15 Yd Pass From Marc Bulger (Jeff Wilkins Kick)
Drive: 6 plays, 62 yds, 2:461710
You must be registered for see images attach
TD12:50
Marcel Shipp 6 Yd Run (Neil Rackers Kick)
Drive: 10 plays, 88 yds, 4:032410FOURTH QUARTERARISTL
You must be registered for see images attach
FG0:30Jeff Wilkins 37 Yd
Drive: 7 plays, 55 yds, 2:402413
You must be registered for see images attach
TD6:46
Marcel Shipp 9 Yd Run (Neil Rackers Kick)
Drive: 4 plays, 19 yds, 2:133113
You must be registered for see images attach
FG13:03Neil Rackers 20 Yd
Drive: 9 plays, 34 yds, 4:383413
You must be registered for see images attach
TD14:25Isaac Bruce 1 Yd Pass From Marc Bulger (Jeff Wilkins Kick)
Drive: 10 plays, 62 yds, 1:223420
Joe-
You did make a good point on Milligan. My hypothetical 14 6th rounder scenerio is merely to point out that trading depth is not wise.
It's clear that you are not a Shipp fan. I am. While my son was autograph-hounding at the team bus at the Rams game last weekend, I was talking to a Cards PR guy, and and guy wearing a Rackers jersey (who I assumed to be Neil's Dad, since they were hanging out before the team bus left.) Both were very clear that Marcel is highly respected on the team and by Wiz, and that prior to training camp, there was some question about how Edge was going to respond to the new system, and Marcel was clearly in the picture for getting a lot of carries. Obviously, that has changed with Edge's performance, but going to Marcel as a second option would not bother this team at all. Dumping him, or any good depth palyer, for a 6th rounder, is not going to happen.
JJ has more touches b/c he is the 3rd down back, and Marcel is the backup RB, as Pariah pointed out.