Kyler Murray Debate Thread

[BritCard]

If we draft a QBotF high, who really cares how Kyler feels about it?

Only in the context of "to sit a year or 2"

 

[BritCard]

On bringing in a vet...

If you want someone that might have a Sam Darnold, Baker Mayfield type resurgence then I'd bring in Carson Wentz and see if you can tap some of that early career form.

At worse he's a better backup than tune. He's had a year in the Rams and Chiefs offenses, both of which are very good.

 

[kerouac9]

On bringing in a vet...

If you want someone that might have a Sam Darnold, Baker Mayfield type resurgence then I'd bring in Carson Wentz and see if you can tap some of that early career form.

At worse he's a better backup than tune. He's had a year in the Rams and Chiefs offenses, both of which are very good.

Barf no.

 

[Shane]

It has been pointed out to me that the Cardinals are O-3 since the latest call of duty release

 

[602 Native]

It has been pointed out to me that the Cardinals are O-3 since the latest call of duty release

COD Launched 10/25/2024

 

[Shane]

COD Launched 10/25/2024

Well damn fake news lol

 

[Redsz]

On bringing in a vet...

If you want someone that might have a Sam Darnold, Baker Mayfield type resurgence then I'd bring in Carson Wentz and see if you can tap some of that early career form.

At worse he's a better backup than tune. He's had a year in the Rams and Chiefs offenses, both of which are very good.

Wentz is cooked. But I would give Darnold or Mayfield a hard look if the Cardinals decided to move off Kyler.

 

[daves]

Wentz is cooked. But I would give Darnold or Mayfield a hard look if the Cardinals decided to move off Kyler.

Mayfield signed a 3-year deal in May.

Buccaneers, QB Baker Mayfield agree to three-year contract worth up to $115 million

 

[602 Native]

xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media

 

[GatorAZ]

Jimmy G turned the ball over more times than he had TDs in both of his 3 game playoff-runs.

Random but Trey Lance might be the worst QB all time when mediocre talents like Brock and Jimmy G are quarterbacking their teams to the NFCCG every year and he couldn’t sniff the field.

 

[DVontel]

Random but Trey Lance might be the worst QB all time when mediocre talents like Brock and Jimmy G are quarterbacking their teams to the NFCCG every year and he couldn’t sniff the field.

Yea, I remember having this convo with some buddies about who was the biggest bust in that class between Zach Wilson & Trey, they said Zach, but Trey had a much better supporting cast & SF spent 3 1st rounders on him. It’s definitely Trey.

 

[ASUCHRIS]

Trey reminded me of Logan Thomas.

 

[HairZach]

Random but Trey Lance might be the worst QB all time when mediocre talents like Brock and Jimmy G are quarterbacking their teams to the NFCCG every year and he couldn’t sniff the field.

Brock's genuinely very good. I'll die on that hill.

 

[kerouac9]

Yea, I remember having this convo with some buddies about who was the biggest bust in that class between Zach Wilson & Trey, they said Zach, but Trey had a much better supporting cast & SF spent 3 1st rounders on him. It’s definitely Trey.

He’s definitely the biggest bust in terms of value to the team, but hard to blame him personally when his body just wasn’t up to the challenge of the NFL.

 

[daves]

I think it is telling that Purdy started 46 games in college and Jimmy G. started 45 games in college.

Kyler started only 17 games in college.

That didn't stop him from winning OROY and going to two Pro Bowls right out of the gate.

After 6 years in the NFL, that's no more relevant than his high school exploits.

 

[Chopper0080]

I would rather see a stacked roster that Kyler is holding back than a barely league average roster with a rookie at QB. Build the roster and then aggressively go get the QB you want.

 

[Cheesebeef]

I would rather see a stacked roster that Kyler is holding back than a barely league average roster with a rookie at QB. Build the roster and then aggressively go get the QB you want.

There is no reason that has to be an either or situation. Why y’all are presenting this false choice over and over again is mystifying. The Broncos JUST did this.

 

[DVontel]

There is no reason that has to be an either or situation. Why y’all are presenting this false choice over and over again is mystifying. The Broncos JUST did this.

Because I “think” the former would be closer to a Super Bowl contender than the latter is what Chop is saying. One example being the Rams being stacked with talent in 2020, McVay felt Goff held them back, went for an upgrade in Stafford, won the SB.

 

[Cheesebeef]

Because I “think” the former would be closer to a Super Bowl contender than the latter is what Chop is saying. One example being the Rams being stacked with talent in 2020, McVay felt Goff held them back, went for an upgrade in Stafford, won the SB.

Okay… but the Rams took several seasons of trades, FA and great drafting to surround Goff enough to get to a Super Bowl. There is no possible way we can do all that in one final offseason with Kyler. And if we could, we wouldn’t because we never spend that kind of money and Monti isn’t close to being the type of draft genius the Rams FO had at that point.

Hoping for that plan is has the same level of reality as hoping the Leprechaun jumps off the Lucky Charms box and leads me to a massive bowl full of gold.

 

[DVontel]

Okay… but the Rams took several seasons of trades, FA and great drafting to surround Goff enough to get to a Super Bowl.

Yea man, so it’s going to take us a couple seasons(hurts to say I know) to hopefully do all of that.

There is no possible way we can do all that in one final offseason with Kyler.

I know. I believe 2026 offseason is key. You can be a playoff-contender overnight. Being a super-bowl contender is another story.

Monti isn’t close to being the type of draft genius the Rams FO had at that point.

Les Snead wasn’t known as a genius until his 6th offseason.

Hoping for that plan is has the same level of reality as hoping the Leprechaun jumps off the Lucky Charms box and leads me to a massive bowl full of gold.

Hopefully that plan becomes a reality. Honestly, look at all the Super Bowl representatives & their QBs the past couple of years. Quality ranging from elite to good to game-manager. Outside of the Bengals, all of those QBs landed on teams with a good bit of talent whether through draft, FA or trade.

 

[kerouac9]

There is no reason that has to be an either or situation. Why y’all are presenting this false choice over and over again is mystifying. The Broncos JUST did this.

They started with a higher baseline because Payton didn’t strip the roster to show the NFL how smart he was