Actually i am a bit psychic.
WTF?
Anyway, yes the SUNS have some poor defensive players.
Some? Who do they have thats good at defense? Of their top 7 guys, only 2 are average at D (Hill and Barnes), the rest are below average.
The notion that D'Antoni's teams are bad defensive teams just because he has bad defensive players and thus is exempt from blame is also silly.
Huh? D'Antoni, Porter, Phill Jackson, Red Aurebach, or whomever can't suddenly take guys (like Nash) who aren't physically capable of being good defenders and turn them into that. And most coaches probably can't motivate a guy like Amare to become a great defender if he doesn't want to be.
D'Antoni's teams will ALWAYS be poor defensive teams...because defense is not important to DA(do you dispute this?).
I think thats way over simplifying things, which you're often prone to do. To say that defense is 'unimportant' to D'Antoni or any NBA coach is ridiculous. If you read ":07 Seconds or Less" or have ever listened to an interview with the guy, you know he doesn't not care about defense. Now, is it his #1 priority? No. But its an over simplification to say he just said "screw it, lets not even try to stop anyone".
Defense is much more important to Porter(do you dispute this?)
Sure, and winning the lottery is important to me, but that doesn't mean its going to magically happen because I will it to.
I see your point as far as having good defensive players...i really do but why take the angle that Porter can't coach it? Thats just not a smart statement.
My point is, no coach is going to turn Nash into a great defender. No coach is going to take Shaqs aging body and turn it into a well oiled machine that can actually move laterally or cover the pick and roll. Very few coaches would probably ever be able to motivate Amare into taking his defense as serious as he takes his offense.
I'm not blaming Porter or D'Antoni for the Suns porous defense, I'm blaming the roster, which I think is the only thing that makes sense. In the NBA when you have the best players, guess what, you usually win. When you have good individual defensive players, your team defense ends up being good. I don't see how this is rocket science or really debatable.
At this point, you're better off vomiting all over yourself than posting on this message board anymore. You contribute nothing of substance and are part of the reason I dont frequent the Suns MB much
Oh but this post was contributing something of substance?
First of all, Barnes is not the starter. Hill is.
Well thats true right now, but Barnes was starting for a while and is still playing more minutes than Hill. So while he may not be the first small forward on the court, he's the primary small forward.
Roy got hot and it didn't matter who was guarding him. You could have had Bowen and Artest guarding him and it wouldn't have made any difference.
I agree, for the most part in the NBA a great offensive player will trump a great defensive player. No one is going to slow Kobe or MJ, or Roy the way he was on fire tonight, so c'est la vie.