I don't know if getting rid of Mac is such a good thing.
We all know Mac isn't a good x's and o's coach.
Would I rather have a guy that was yes!!!
But where is there one out there? (obviously I'm not paid to make such determinations)
If you can get a billick, bellicheck, cowher, etc....or get some up and comer then it might be good.
But I don't see those types of guys out there for the taking right now.....I liked Marvin lewis and jack del rio last year, but of course I wasn't calling for macs job.
I don't wanna see mac lose his job for another retread coach like we've done with qb's
We have two good coaches on our team imo, mcginnis, and sullivan.
Except sullivan shouldn't be our oc, he should be our wr coach.
Mac should be our hc.....who delegates the playcalling to TWO good beyond competent coaches....A great oc, and a great dc.
The guys haven't given up on mac...even if it looks bad.
But after these years of losing and them still believing in mac and we let him loose....what happens if potentially next year or the year after we're in the same position with a new coach...then they may stop believing....
What I mean by this is that I think they won't quit on Mac this year....won't next year either....give him some talent..both on the field AND on playcalling and use Mcginnis as he should be used, as a facilitator who can rally the troops and we'll be fine.
I'm not saying we should steadfastly keep mcginnis. But I don't think that if we fire him, we're going to get a guy who is gonna put us in a better position whether you look at it short or long term.
Every personel decision you make should be made (sans cap wise) on the point it will make your football team better. Never make a decision that won't make your team better, unless you are biting the bullet. But we've bit the bullet time after time after time. I think we need stop biting the bullet and start surrounding what we DO have with good/great players and coaches.
No more letting good players get away...No more letting good coahces go. (stallings....national champ in college a year later, don coryell although it was before my time....fassel...some might even say bugel). Lets keep mcginnis as our rah rah guy, and put the people we know can do good....around him....
What we really need is better assistant coaches all the way down the line. Keep Mcginnis, demote sullivan, fire everyone else...our st are a joke, our defense is a joke, our ol after warhop (who most said sucked...and I never disagreed) is halfway a joke, our dl has either underachieved or has been a joke throughout green's tenure.
The one thing that was said on fox (besides bradshaws comments) was that we didn't pay enough to put the right people in position to make decisions on the coaching staff...we'll lets change that.
Ugh, another double digit losing season...hopefully we'll get eli...except if we are behind the raiders we'll never get him...
If we are ahead, we may trade down to avoid a 50-72 mill contract
If we trade down it better be to like number 5-7...so we get another 1st round and a later pick...then we trade down again if it seems no one we want is worth it (too early to tell now) for another first round pick.
If we can get 3 first round picks this years plus another pick later it might be something to smile about....but we need to focus on who will be throwing the ball at the new Cardinals land in 06.