red desert
ASFN Addict
Guy was electric in his system in college but I have vibes, bad vibes about Tavon
Fair enough.
Guy was electric in his system in college but I have vibes, bad vibes about Tavon
You can't, or shouldn't, take a guy that small in the top 10. His athletcism won't be as big a factor at the NFL level and his lack of size will be even a bigger factor. Also, I don't want to take a #3 slot WR in the top 10.
Denard Robinson was as big a playmker in college and he's being talked about as a day 3 draft pick. Granted, he's changing positions but Austin is more of an athlete than a polished NFL type WR. The same can be said for to a greater extent about Robinson.
Welker is a slot receiver. Would you say that he is a part time player? I wouldn't considering he was on the field for almost every single offensive play for NE. Being a slot receiver doesn't mean that he won't see plenty of playing time.Glad there is someone who can bring some logic to this group. If you draft a part time player in round 1, you deserve what you get.
Welker is a slot receiver. Would you say that he is a part time player? I wouldn't considering he was on the field for almost every single offensive play for NE. Being a slot receiver doesn't mean that he won't see plenty of playing time.
I started a thread about a month ago stating Austin was the most dynamic player in this years draft. I still believe that. I have tried to stay out of this thread b/c I am a WVU homer and think Smith, Austin, and Bailey should all go 1st round Kidding of course..
And as much as I like TA I dont see the Cards drafting him at #7 and there is now way he is there past #14 or #16 pick. But the kid is special.
What makes him special? Well of course his speed, but that really isnt it, its his wiggle, start and stop, change of direction. I have never, NEVER seen anyone that mkaes people miss like he does. He splits defenders and breaks their ankles. Its pretty amazing. When guys have angles on him he outruns them or cuts back and spins them around. His vision with the ball in his hands borders on legendary.
One thing to keep in mind is he came out of Dunbar HS in MD as a RB (and still holds a ton of RB records for the state) and was not red shirted his first year. He was stuck behind Noel Devine and returned kicks/punts and got some play at RB. By his second year the coaches were smart enough to realize he is so great in space so they moved him to slot receiver. He did drop some balls that year and was told by the WR coach he needs to practice like its a game. He has done that and more ever since. The kid is a gamer and do not let his size fool you. He is tough as nails and outside of a wrist injury his Junior year has played through every nick and cut.
I dont disagree with people who say he is too small but I do disgaree that he will get hurt in the nfl. I have seen him take maybe 1 or 2 solid hits in his college career bc he just doesnt let anyone get a hold of him. There is no reason to think that will change in the NFL. He is still going to be the best 1 or 2 athletes on the field for any given game. He is that good.
He will make an impact in the NFL and you will see his plays on Sportcenter, but with the current state of the Cardinals, drafting him is a luxury they probably cant afford. But we very well could be lamenting the day the Cards passed on him, a la Adrian Peterson.
Yes, if you point to the best slot receiver in the NFL who plays in a pass first offense, he plays about 70% of the snaps. Which is still a part time position.
Drafting Austin in the first round is like drafting a run stopping middle linebacker in the first round. Or a Fullback.
Even if he only plays in 70% of the plays he would still likely put up full time numbers out of those plays. What makes him different especially than a FB is the fact that he is a big time play maker and there are only so many of those in the NFL.Yes, if you point to the best slot receiver in the NFL who plays in a pass first offense, he plays about 70% of the snaps. Which is still a part time position.
Drafting Austin in the first round is like drafting a run stopping middle linebacker in the first round. Or a Fullback.
Breathe.... relax... and think about what you just posted. Austin is the same as drafting a Fullback? Really?
Haters are gonna hate
It's gonna be hilarious when we draft Lane Johnson & he turns out to be a mediocre player because we drafted for need just like good ol Levi Brown or possibly Dion Jordan.
Thank you! Ok, you're in the club. Dues requirements and rules will be sent via email. Mitch is President, I'm Vice, you can be Secretary.
As to you last point that TA is a luxury Cards probably can't afford, I reply with, "How can ANY team not afford to draft such a talent?"
Breathe.... relax... and think about what you just posted. Austin is the same as drafting a Fullback? Really?
I am just saying that I would never draft a part time player in the first round...especially on a team that needs every down players.
Obviously any skill position is going to outproduce a Fullback.
I don't know about the first round. I'm at loggerheads with Chopper about this, but I'd be fine with drafting a nose tackle or 3rd corner in the first round.
But I wouldn't draft a part-time player with a Top 10 pick. That's insanity. If you just needed to get 40% better on 70% of your plays, you wouldn't be picking in the top 10.
How did I get bunked down to Secretary? Ive been watching this kid for 4 years!~
I dont know why you keep jocking on a Desean Jackson clone....give it a rest already
Mitch, you reference the head case aspect of DeSean's game. Good point.
One big upside with TA that is not talked about enough is his grounded nature and apparent lack of prima donna mindset. THAT ALONE makes him arguably a better draft prospect than say, Patterson this year, or DeSean when he came out. Not saying Patterson is going to get arrested when he gets into the league but one year removed from JC ball, has he proven enough? I think so, but just saying. How much production has Dez, or Brandon Marshall left rotting on the sideline by their topsy turvy mental shenanigans? We all know that the list of wideouts with this sort of hovering danger is long...
Anquan is already referring to TA and mini me.
Another thought on TA, and why his lack of prototypical stature is overplayed.
If we can get 4 or 5 years of game changing brilliance, I'm good. As a first round pick, you get that, you hit a home run. Not a grand slam maybe (see: Fitz, AP, Farve, etc...) but a home run.
Sure beats a "solid" starter for 8 years. Just my opinion. And no, Levi Brown does not even sniff the "solid" starter category.
For the record, I think TA can be great for 6-8 years.