Whos big four would you rather have?

[Shane]

Arizona:

Warner
James
Boldin
Fitz

or

Dallas:

Bledsoe
Jones
Owens
Glenn



Only reason I ask is that I was in a debate at work the other night and I had three different people saying they would take the Cowboys 4 over ours. They stated that overall they had more potential and a better O-line. I personally think they are insane. If you look at what Fitz, Boldin, and Edge have accomplished already and are still in the 22-27 YOA range. As compared to Glenn, Owens who are both 32+ and Jones. Anyone who would take Jones over Edge is just nuts. I think Bledsoe and Warner are a wash although Warners resume would look better.

 

[BigRedRage]

whomever you were debating with doesnt know much about our big 4

 

[Duckjake]

Arizona:

Warner
James
Boldin
Fitz

or

Dallas:

Bledsoe
Jones
Owens
Glenn



Only reason I ask is that I was in a debate at work the other night and I had three different people saying they would take the Cowboys 4 over ours. They stated that overall they had more potential and a better O-line. I personally think they are insane. If you look at what Fitz, Boldin, and Edge have accomplished already and are still in the 22-27 YOA range. As compared to Glenn, Owens who are both 32+ and Jones. Anyone who would take Jones over Edge is just nuts. I think Bledsoe and Warner are a wash although Warners resume would look better.

That's the #1 reason, among others, I voted for Arizona's guys.

 

[DieHardFromMO]

Not much to debate. I would take the Cards 4 without any hesitation at all.

 

[earthsci]

...and a better O-line.

That's the only thing that may be true.

 

[DieHardFromMO]

Based on the poll results thus far it appears this message board has been invaded by a Cowboy fan.

 

[Redsz]

There's two of them!

 

[Second Deck]

I cannot imagine any fan really wanting TO on their team. To me it is not even close. I take Boldin Fitz Warner and the EDge anyday. Lets go on and ask the question would you trade our big four for any other.

 

[LVCARDFREAK]

No, I accidently clicked the wrong one...I would much rather have the Cards 4....any dallas totals should be minus 1

 

[Zeno]

What a stupid question!

Cardinals in a landslide.

 

[Shane]

What a stupid question!

Cardinals in a landslide.

Ok since its a stupid ?

How about this: Would you interchange any of the two groups if you could? If so what would be perfect to you? I personally wouldnt change the Cards four at all.

 

[JasonKGME]

Ok since its a stupid ?

How about this: Would you interchange any of the two groups if you could? If so what would be perfect to you? I personally wouldnt change the Cards four at all.

Can we trade O-Lines???

 

[Beaver]

The question is: What 4 from any team would you rather have?

 

[football karma]

Here is the thing about offensive lines:

As bad as AZ was last year, Dallas was just as bad:

AZ's average yard per rush was 3.2, Dallas was 3.6 -- both bottom 10 in the league.

Cards gave up 45 sacks, Dallas gave up 50 -- on far fewer pass attempts

Anyone who says that Dallas' offensive line is significantly better, or even better , doesnt know what they are talking about

 

[Codeofhammurabi]

Here is the thing about offensive lines:

As bad as AZ was last year, Dallas was just as bad:

AZ's average yard per rush was 3.2, Dallas was 3.6 -- both bottom 10 in the league.

Cards gave up 45 sacks, Dallas gave up 50 -- on far fewer pass attempts

Anyone who says that Dallas' offensive line is significantly better, or even better , doesnt know what they are talking about

Dallas also had two running backs that most would consider better than ours last season.

 

[BigDavis75]

There are only a few other notable "big 4s," none of which I would take over ours.

Cincy
New Orleans
Carolina
Indy (as long as they have a decent RB, Maroney?)
Giants

 

[Crazy Canuck]

Jerry Jones would take the CARDS four in a Dallas minute...

 

[Ouchie-Z-Clown]

That's the only thing that may be true.

yeah, but it may mean the difference between us making the playoffs and the cowpukes making the playoffs.

just looking at the four skill positions it's no contest, we're better. but the oline could kill us again.

 

[Ouchie-Z-Clown]

There are only a few other notable "big 4s," none of which I would take over ours.

Cincy
New Orleans
Carolina
Indy (as long as they have a decent RB, Maroney?)
Giants

hmm, i'd have to take cincy's (assuming palmer comes back healthy) over ours. i think chad is the best wr, then our two, then housh. palmer is a lot better than warner, and considering y'all were taking age into consideration . . . a lot younger. and i think rudi and edge are fairly equivalent, maybe an slight nod to edge. but the qb comparison skews in favor of cincy incredibly.

for the same reason i would take indy's. harrison/wayne is fairly equivalent to q/fitz (though again we have the edge in age), if they find a good rb it may be a wash with a slight edge to edge. so we have a slight edge in two categories. but then the peyton verses warner comparison kills the cards four imo.

 

[HooverDam]

Ok so who is the one person who voted for Dallas? I really want to hear an explanation, because thats just insane.

 

[Assface]

Ok so who is the one person who voted for Dallas? I really want to hear an explanation, because thats just insane.

Dallas votes: LVCARDFREAK, Mrh182

 

[Stout]

There are only a few other notable "big 4s," none of which I would take over ours.

Cincy
New Orleans
Carolina
Indy (as long as they have a decent RB, Maroney?)
Giants

New Orleans? Brees, Horn, and....? An injured Deuce? And...?

Giants...Eli and Tiki (not as good as Edge), and.....? Shockey? Burress?

 

[dreamcastrocks]

Arizona:

Warner
James
Boldin
Fitz

or

Dallas:

Bledsoe
Jones
Owens
Glenn

You may be able to use the BIG4 from their hayday and a lot of people will still pick the AZ team

Aikman
Smith
Irvin
"Moose" or the TE whos name is slipping my mind

 

[Shane]

New Orleans? Brees, Horn, and....? An injured Deuce? And...?

Giants...Eli and Tiki (not as good as Edge), and.....? Shockey? Burress?

You cant even use Eli. Any QB who completes 51% his passes cant be considered big anything. JMHO.

 

[duckfallas]

No brainer. Owens will implode on that team too eventually. Hopefully sooner.