Kyler Murray Debate Thread

[PDXChris]

Dude, he walked into the best imaginable situation at every stop in his career before arriving here. When he encountered minor adversity at A&M he immediately transferred.

Like Jayden Daniels at ASU?

 

[MaoTosiFanClub]

Lamar was AWESOME his rookie season. He went 6-1 after Joe Flacco lead them to a desultory 4-5 record in the first half of the season. Really struggled in the playoffs, fumbling three times.

Yep you’re right. Had him mixed up with Allen from that class.

 

[MaoTosiFanClub]

Like Jayden Daniels at ASU?

Anyone who knows anything about college football knows why Kyler got out of A&M. The “minor adversity” there was his head coach being a full blown alcoholic. Getting away from Sumlin was the smartest decision of Kyler’s life.

 

[Russ Smith]

That's exactly what I and most of the free world are saying. That pass was not accurately thrown. I'll bet the K1 would tell you it could have been better located. And a pass over the middle on a crossing pattern is not remotely close to a pass in the red zone where the field is condensed.

I don't read everything but I would say half of the free world is saying how does a ball hit the TE in his helmet and how was that pick not overturned when they reviewed it. Because that's what I'm seeing online. Half are saying needs to lead him more and the other half are saying the problem is he hadn't turned to look, because of the contact in the endzone.

The only thing I can say there is he could have waited a split second longer but again we've spent the last several years hearing Kyler can't throw guys open, he won't throw the ball if the guys not open. He threw that ball as the guy was still getting free from the contact in the endzone, it hit the guy right in his helmet directly above his hands in a straight line. and that's still a bad throw apparently?

It's an absolute fluke play, sure if it's lower and outside when Trey doesn't see it, the ball probably hits the ground. And now we'd have a 50 page thread about how Kyler has him wide open for the game winner and throws it into the ground

 

[kerouac9]

Anyone who knows anything about college football knows why Kyler got out of A&M. The “minor adversity” there was his head coach being a full blown alcoholic. Getting away from Sumlin was the smartest decision of Kyler’s life.

I dunno. That extension he signed has been pretty great so far.

Just to say that literally everyone who mattered in Kyler's life believed in him 100% and any haters he's experienced have been well outside his circle. This is not like Josh Allen only getting a QB offer at Wyoming or Aaron Rodgers having to play QB at JuCo.

 

[MaoTosiFanClub]

I dunno. That extension he signed has been pretty great so far.

Just to say that literally everyone who mattered in Kyler's life believed in him 100% and any haters he's experienced have been well outside his circle. This is not like Josh Allen only getting a QB offer at Wyoming or Aaron Rodgers having to play QB at JuCo.

That’s not what you were trying to say. You were trying to make a point about his character without knowing anything about the background of his transfer.

Had he stayed with Sumlin he never would’ve gotten the opportunity to sign that contract.

 

[kerouac9]

That’s not what you were trying to say. You were trying to make a point about his character without knowing anything about the background of his transfer.

Had he stayed with Sumlin he never would’ve gotten the opportunity to sign that contract.

Fair enough. I was saying the latter, what I was trying to say is that the path has been smoothed for Kyler Murray's success from Pop Warner football forward and there has been no one in a position of authority over him who hasn't believed in him up to this very moment.

 

[MaoTosiFanClub]

xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media

5 minute mark.

Keim feeding Cowherd stuff on Kyler’s work ethic was funny. The rest of it not off the mark.

 

[Russ Smith]

Anyone who knows anything about college football knows why Kyler got out of A&M. The “minor adversity” there was his head coach being a full blown alcoholic. Getting away from Sumlin was the smartest decision of Kyler’s life.

They also lied to him during his recruitment. They told him they had no issues with him playing baseball and were fully behind it. Then his freshman year he and Kyle Allen were competing at QB, he was the backup, then started 2 games, and then Allen replaced him again. When he transferred to OU his dad was pretty vocal that they did it because TAM had made it pretty clear as long as Kyler played baseball it was going to impact his ability to be the QB. He's been pretty open about it in the past, he was all set to play infield for TAM and then the football coaches started implying it was going to impact his winning the QB job.

His dad was a huge issue when he was younger. People really ought to read up on Kevin Murray, a BIG reason there was so much skepticism on Kyler in college was because of his dad. His dad flaked on EVERY situation he was in his entire career. Kept insisting he was committed to the situation he was in, and then would bolt. I'm committed to football, then but I'm going to play baseball etc. So when the dad appeared to control his recruitment and then his transfer it was a huge red flag for Kyler

 

[Dr. Jones]

This, from the weighty depths of zero days, zero months, and zero years as an NFL Player Personnel Coordinator.

You're no more qualified to opine on Kyler Murray's NFL future than Captain Crunch.

Hey Now!

What I lack in NFL coaching, or scouting experience, I more than make up for with multiple decades of sitting-my-ass-on-a-couch-for-10-plus-hours-each-football-Sunday experience!

#TradeOffs

 

[Crimson Warrior]

They also lied to him during his recruitment. They told him they had no issues with him playing baseball and were fully behind it. Then his freshman year he and Kyle Allen were competing at QB, he was the backup, then started 2 games, and then Allen replaced him again. When he transferred to OU his dad was pretty vocal that they did it because TAM had made it pretty clear as long as Kyler played baseball it was going to impact his ability to be the QB. He's been pretty open about it in the past, he was all set to play infield for TAM and then the football coaches started implying it was going to impact his winning the QB job.

His dad was a huge issue when he was younger. People really ought to read up on Kevin Murray, a BIG reason there was so much skepticism on Kyler in college was because of his dad. His dad flaked on EVERY situation he was in his entire career. Kept insisting he was committed to the situation he was in, and then would bolt. I'm committed to football, then but I'm going to play baseball etc. So when the dad appeared to control his recruitment and then his transfer it was a huge red flag for Kyler

I wish Kyler's Dad was a lot more out of the picture.

If you were like, actually working for your Dad at a family owned business or something, that's one thing.

But your dad being around all the time as like a "life coach" or whatever... that doesn't seem very normal or healthy.

 

[TJ]

Keim feeding Cowherd stuff on Kyler’s work ethic was funny. The rest of it not off the mark.

Keim or otherwise, Kyler's work ethic has been questioned by many. He obviously takes care of his body, but not the intangibles. As Colin said, he's not gonna age well and would need a Randall Cunningham-type retooling to be productive, and Kyler simply doesnt have the function to be a QB who beats teams with superior intellect rather than athleticism.

 

[TJ]

Thought exercise: In 2019, would it have been better to ride with Josh Rosen one more season and to draft Nick Bosa or trade back? If Rosen doesnt pan out, you abandon ship in 2020 and are likely to be in position to draft Herbert, Burrow, Tua, etc. and still have an elite pass rusher.

 

[slanidrac16]

xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media

Exactly. But there are many on this board that are willing to watch something else, but who? Justin Fields? Kenny Pickett? Tune? Winston?Cousins… please no.
Could we trade Kyler for a first round pick to a team drafting in the top 5?
Is there a Qb coming out of college worthy and could he step in on day one like Daniels or Williams?

Everything…EVERYTHING points to Kyler being our qb next and perhaps beyond.

 

[Crimson Warrior]

Hey Now!

What I lack in NFL coaching, or scouting experience, I more than make up for with multiple decades of sitting-my-ass-on-a-couch-for-10-plus-hours-each-football-Sunday experience!

#TradeOffs

ha! Joking with you a little Dr., certainly.

You being so ready to shovel earth onto our QB1s grave, even at this juncture, is just the slightest bit off-putting . Ever so slightly. Forgive me for saying so.

I'll concede Murray may not ever win a playoff game in his career. Once unthinkable, it's unfortunately quite possible now, six years into his career, and with his current inability to make plays at critical moments in meaningful games. Now it's maybe a coinflip.

I doubt he finds that acceptable though. Can he do anything about it? That remains to be seen.

Happy New Year!

 

[Russ Smith]

I wish Kyler's Dad was a lot more out of the picture.

If you were like, actually working for your Dad at a family owned business or something, that's one thing.

But your dad being around all the time as like a "life coach" or whatever... that doesn't seem very normal or healthy.

I don't know if he still is I thought I read somethign a year or two ago about Kyler breaking off of that?

But yeah when he was younger everyone was concerned Kyler would do what his dad did because of his dad.

I'm a UCLA basketball fan not so much football but it was well known UCLA recruited Kyler. They knew they had no chance getting him on football alone but because of baseball they thought they had a chance. His dad apparently led the program along for quite awhile all the while knowing full well they weren't going to UCLA.

 

[MaoTosiFanClub]

Exactly. But there are many on this board that are willing to watch something else, but who? Justin Fields? Kenny Pickett? Tune? Winston?Cousins… please no.
Could we trade Kyler for a first round pick to a team drafting in the top 5?
Is there a Qb coming out of college worthy and could he step in on day one like Daniels or Williams?

Everything…EVERYTHING points to Kyler being our qb next and perhaps beyond.

The 2026 QB draft class looks pretty loaded. Manning, Leavitt (hometown), Allar, South Carolina QB, etc. short of getting a monster offer my guess is we ride it out for a year.

 

[Crimson Warrior]

I think Kyler can follow the team to 11 regular season wins in 2025 based on a soft schedule. Of course, if he wins nine games and misses the playoffs, I'm certain you'll be here to remind us to keep an open mind about Kyler Murray as a starting quarterback in 2026.

Even I, K1's most enthusiastic Superfan here at ASFN, would have a tough time endorsing Murray for 2026 if we failed to make the post season in 2025 (baring extraordinary extenuating 2025 circumstances of course).

I feel pretty confident we'll make the playoffs next year however.

 

[Crimson Warrior]

I don't know if he still is I thought I read somethign a year or two ago about Kyler breaking off of that?

But yeah when he was younger everyone was concerned Kyler would do what his dad did because of his dad.

I'm a UCLA basketball fan not so much football but it was well known UCLA recruited Kyler. They knew they had no chance getting him on football alone but because of baseball they thought they had a chance. His dad apparently led the program along for quite awhile all the while knowing full well they weren't going to UCLA.

Possibly. But Murray was putting out some Youtube content earlier in the year, including the preseason trip to UCLA, and I think his Dad was around in those videos. I could be wrong.

 

[WisconsinCard]

I don't read everything but I would say half of the free world is saying how does a ball hit the TE in his helmet and how was that pick not overturned when they reviewed it. Because that's what I'm seeing online. Half are saying needs to lead him more and the other half are saying the problem is he hadn't turned to look, because of the contact in the endzone.

The only thing I can say there is he could have waited a split second longer but again we've spent the last several years hearing Kyler can't throw guys open, he won't throw the ball if the guys not open. He threw that ball as the guy was still getting free from the contact in the endzone, it hit the guy right in his helmet directly above his hands in a straight line. and that's still a bad throw apparently?

It's an absolute fluke play, sure if it's lower and outside when Trey doesn't see it, the ball probably hits the ground. And now we'd have a 50 page thread about how Kyler has him wide open for the game winner and throws it into the ground

We're just going to have to agree to disagree.

 

[WisconsinCard]

I think if we have a good offseason Kyler can lead the team to 11 regular season wins in 2025.

Hopefully that would be good enough for you kerouac9.

What happened to the fat lady that was warming up?

 

[WeBlitz]

Thought exercise: In 2019, would it have been better to ride with Josh Rosen one more season and to draft Nick Bosa or trade back? If Rosen doesnt pan out, you abandon ship in 2020 and are likely to be in position to draft Herbert, Burrow, Tua, etc. and still have an elite pass rusher.

Tua does not belong with Burrow or Herbert. We would be in the same position (arguably even worse) if Tua was our QB instead of Kyler.

 

[SoonerLou]

Possibly. But Murray was putting out some Youtube content earlier in the year, including the preseason trip to UCLA, and I think his Dad was around in those videos. I could be wrong.

I have more issues with his dad controlling QB stuff more than any power dynamics.

What are they actively working on to work around the height limitations. Still think he needs another voice. Just training like a normal 6'2" QB isnt working.

 

[DVontel]

The 2026 QB draft class looks pretty loaded. Manning, Leavitt (hometown), Allar, South Carolina QB, etc. short of getting a monster offer my guess is we ride it out for a year.

Manning will probably stay all 4 years like his uncles.

 

[Stout]

xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media

Oh please oh please oh please...