No
Part of my words are based on the assumption that uprooting a 17 year old child and having him come here and adjust to that (including language barrier), plus chemistry with his new teammates might be too much to ask. However if he was a homegrown talent from good ol USA, I would believe he would have the talent to do that. It's not the talent I question in him achieving it this year, it would be the outside factors. So perhaps I drop back on my statement a bit, because of that. But again talent wise, he already has it to do that, and much, much more.
As for the trade. It's potential versus a known factor. You would have many intangibles assuming this is not right now. As obviously Amare wouldn't be necessary to get him this year, if Rubio was available.
Maybe 2 years from now, Amare's knees are shot, maybe we suck and he says I'm outta here at the end of the year, who knows. Under a scenario like that it would be more conceivable, assuming he was drafted by another team, and we'd have to have them include either expiring contracts, overpaid bums, or perhaps the market suggests you get a pretty good player with a pretty expensive contract. Who knows what the market would hold at that point.
Being a Suns fan, considering our history, I would always lean against towards trading away a big man. If you consider we potentially have dragic in place, we may not need a pg, and might have bigger needs. We don't know if dragic will pan out, but he's here and we'll find out.
Even though nash is getting old, there's no reason to think he can't play for 4-5 more years. Two years from now Nash still might be playing pretty well. I wont say 4-5 years from now he will still be playing, and if he did that he'd play at the same level of play, or even close. But if his back holds up, and he has the desire to play, play here, and not make as much, he could still be here. So Nash and Dragic might prevent any realistic thought of trading for Rubio.
If we did trade, then we'd have no Amare, we'd probably have Nash, Dragic, Rubio. That's hella talented, but would it help you win more games? No.
A different team might be in a different position. A guy similar to Amare's skill for him would be understandable if they aren't loaded at pg.
But also I believe I wouldn't do it because it wouldn't be neccessary at this point. Two years from now, if he's expected to go #1 overall, Amare (or a similar skill player on a different team) for a #1 overall and one of the above scenarios to make the trade work might appear to be enough. However will he be thought of as a #1 or not? Maybe he lands 2nd-6th because he is a point guard. You need five players on the court, and Rubio plays just one, but oh does he play it well. That position is obviously important, but lots of teams favor big men, so Rubio as being the best player in the draft, might not go #1.
He might even enter the draft the way dragic did, and might slip to the 2nd round, where a bidding war might erupt, or maybe not based on the same or different factors that allowed dragic to fall like he did.
Lets not forget there's a good chance he won't want to come over here, so all of this might be moot.
However I stand by what I see as a potential to be a HOF player. The kid can handle that ball like a master, and clearly to me at least, has the mindset of a pg in deciding how to distribute the rock and run an offense. That mindset already looks like a veteran point guard. Which at 17 is simply amazing. If that's where he is now, how about 22, how about 25? Then think at 25, he still could have 10-12 more years in the league. Scary good.
I would never try to trade Amare for this kid, because I'm confident I could get him cheaper, and pair with Amare. But what do you do about Nash and potentially Dragic. It might just turn out the best thing to do, is not getting him until those situations present themselves. Maybe he's a 25 year old fa, maybe you trade for him after Nash retires, et cetera. Hard to look into the future. I wouldn't rule it out, but I'd be crazy to say, yeah, I'd do it today given the realities of the situation.