More noise. He's averaging 27 minutes per game. It's not reasonable to praise him for rebounding better than someone who only plays 11 minutes per game and it's equally unreasonable to demand he pull down as many boards as a power forward logging 40 minutes per game. You took a shot at him because he didn't rebound as well as the guys you mentioned and yet it turns out he's rebounding at a better rate than 2 of the 3 guys you compared him to.
You weren't posting here at that time so I really don't know how you felt about him back then. I do know you have been avidly against him from the beginning of your time on this board. There were times when it was justified but you're coming here with the same tired stuff and ignoring all that he has done for us this season.
It's hard to say he's not living up to his salary this season. There are 106 players making more than him. If you ignore the players still on their initial contract, I don't see how you can possibly come up with 106 players that are doing a better job of earning their paychecks out there.
Actually, I think his help defense is much better than his low post defense (which can be pretty atrocious at times). He's had a handful of obvious blunders (or he's been a part of them, we'll never really know who's blew their responsibility) but for the most part he's rotated when he should and he's doubled when he should. He's not a great defender but this is by far the best I've seen him play at that end of the court.
Blocks? Who freaking cares about blocked shot stats? How many championships did Dikembe win? Do you really think if he averaged 1 more block per game that we'd be noticeably better than we are right now. And one more blocked shot per game would put him right there with Miles who is 8th in the league.
He scores in double digits about 75% of the time. NBA players have up games and down games and it's even more true if your game is mostly putting up 3 pointers. I'd like a little more consistency from him too but some of his down nights are the result of our depth. He misses his first couple shots and the Morris twins come in and get hot and the next thing you know he's logging 17 to 23 minutes instead of his usual 27 to 31 minutes. There's a reason that he's only logging one minute more per game than Markieff despite the fact that Morris doesn't start.
I didn't say it affected his defensive stats. It decreases his opportunities to pull down offensive boards. 4.5 defensive rebounds for a guy that only plays 27 minutes isn't horrible. My guess, it's somewhere around average for a forward that specializes in long distance shooting.
You really need to stop watching reruns from a couple of years ago. Your comments are so dated and so inaccurate for this year's version of team and player. Jeff doesn't give him the chance to kill us, if Frye is not the answer Jeff goes elsewhere. That's why he's playing 27 minutes per game. And he doesn't just take 3's. He takes 4 to 5 regular shots per game in addition to his three's. He usually sets up outside the arc but when the defender has overplayed him he's blown by him for a layup or slam dunk on many occasions this season.
The biggest problem here though is that you are ignoring the things that don't show up in his box score. Take Frye off of this team and we have less success penetrating and our offensive rebounds would take a huge hit too. You're also ignoring the fact he is shooting .421 from three point range. Shooting .333 from distance nets the same as shooting .500 from two point range. Shooting at his volume and making them at a .421 clip is an incredible asset to this club.
He's not a star and he can still be a liability at times but look around the NBA, that describes most of the starters in this league. We're getting plenty of bang for our buck from Channing this season. Just the simple fact that the other team has to game plan for him makes everyone else's job a little easier. Two years ago we would have had to toss in a player and maybe a pick to get rid of him. This year there are a lot of teams that would offer real value for a chance to add him to their roster. And that doesn't include the leadership he's provided for this young squad (according to his teammates).
My suggestion to you: Lay off the guy until he goes south again. History suggests that will happen. But this year, the guy has been pretty special for us. You ought to give him his due.
Steve
How are you ok with 5 rebounds a game from a PF that plays 27 mins? It blows my mind. I am going to assume that you (along with every other Suns fan in the world) were constantly bashing Amare for his rebounding when he was here but Frye with 5 is ok?
And doesn't matter if there's 106 players who are paid more than Frye. Frye isn't a top 80 or probably even top 100 player. Just cause there a few who are overpaid like him doesn't justify him not living up to the deal.
I'm glad you noticed that all he does is 3pt shooting as well. Any player who only focuses on 3pt shooting will be inconsistent throughout their whole career. Even the great Ray Allen didn't rely on 3pt shooting for all his pts in his prime. Frye chucking doesn't give him the excuse to be inconsistent.
And btw, Frye has scored in double digits 50% of the time this season, not 75%.
Here is Frye's game log for December:
9 pts vs GSW
7 pts vs LAL
18 pts vs DAL
3 pts vs DEN
22 pts vs SAS
20 pts vs GSW
11 pts vs SAC
11 pts vs LAL
2 pts vs TOR
14 pts vs HOU
8 pts vs MEM
Awful consistency.
And just because this is the best defense Frye has played doesn't mean that he's playing good defense. The smartest kid in a class full of mentally challenged kids isn't smart.
You are right that Hornacek doesn't give Frye the chance to kill us. That's one of the main things I like about Hornacek and one of the things I hated about Gentry. But that doesn't make Frye good. You think Horncaek is happy with having to pull his starter because he's playing like crap? Uh no.
And you don't think Kieff can fill Frye's role? I agree that if you take Frye off the team, penetrating will be more difficult for Dragic and Bledsoe but Kieff can do what Frye does and actually play better defense and rebound. And we just need someone who can knock down jumpers and has an inside game like LMA, Amare in his prime, Dirk, Millsap, Horford, Love etc.
I'm curious about this "real value" that we can get for Frye. What do you think we can get?