Chaplin
Better off silent
Hmm, I don't remember it that way. Not to give you a spoiler or anything, but that doesn't make any sense given the way the show goes. Sorry if that's a spoiler.
Lost
- Thread starter Mike Olbinski
- Start date
Hmm, I don't remember it that way. Not to give you a spoiler or anything, but that doesn't make any sense given the way the show goes. Sorry if that's a spoiler.
Okay, I probably just heard wrong.
Chaplin
Better off silent
No, what you said actually makes sense at that time. I may have to go back and watch that ep again.
What I meant was, wouldn't most people think that someone lied about their name? If they didn't know how many people died, they wouldn't know how many people were still alive. They made a big issue about there being an extra person in their count.
However, I don't want to learn any more than I already know, so I should probably not think about this anymore.
Chaplin
Better off silent
WHY would he lie about his name? That's a red flag already. And it's not like anybody on the plane knew everybody else. It all went back to 47 survivors, but only 46 of them are on the manifest. If Ethan had given one of the names of the dead, then there probably wouldn't be any problem.
Wow, watching Lost for the first time....
enjoy the ride...quite an awesome experience.
enjoy the ride...quite an awesome experience.
If someone here has the DVD’s, it would be cool if they would rewatch the specific part when Hurley was collecting the names and prove me wrong. I thought for sure that someone told Hurley that they crossed off the names of the dead.
Several people have been giving false names. Hurley is actually Hugo or something, Kate was called Maggie in her flashback, Sawyer is using a false name.
I’ve just been thinking about this show wayyyy too much. I wouldn’t recommend watching 12 episodes in less than a week, it starts to mess with your mind.
On a side note, I was just thinking during the last episode that the dog must be having the time of his life. He’s totally oblivious to what’s going on and he gets to run wild on an island. I really hope nothing bad happens to the dog.
Hold that thought.......
(and no, that is not really a spoiler, just more an observation - the rest of us are as clueless about Vincent's role in all of this as you).
Wow. Thanks, I’ll pay more attention to the dog now. I was pretty happy when they found him early on because my older yellow lab looks just like him.
Luckily I hadn't sent back the dvd yet, so I rewatched this part.
It was Boone that said this to Hurley. He said "You know, your life would be much easier if you just had the manifest, because we crossed off all the names of the dead after we burned the fuselage. So, there should be a full roster of the rest of us."
I know what you mean though, it seems like it would be almost impossible to identify all of the dead.
Chaplin
Better off silent
Sounds like it might be a rare plot hole.
I’ve just been thinking about this show wayyyy too much. I wouldn’t recommend watching 12 episodes in less than a week, it starts to mess with your mind.
Oh, this show will mess with your mind even when you watch just one episode a week, lol! I think this thread is proof of that!!!
Premier is getting closer!
Premier is getting closer!
http://www.wsu.edu/~brians/errors/premier.html
Please pass the link on to Chandler Mike.
I did not know that about premier/premiere. Thanks.
Bah! Thanks.
OP
OP
got some friends together and we are having a LOST season opener party tomorrow night. It should be fun. I can't wait to see what is going to happen.
Woot!
shawn
Woot!
shawn
OP
OP
i would have invited you mike - but i thought you might be travelling in Uganda or some place exotic like that.
shawn
OP
OP
i would have invited you mike - but i thought you might be travelling in Uganda or some place exotic like that.
shawn
The Alps this year probably...and when you have your Oscar party, I think I'll be in Paraguay...
Mike
I have now read up to about post #300. I just finished off episode #16. I just about fell off the treadmill last night when the “beast” jumped out of the bushes and started chasing Shannon and Boone. (I’m glad that I finally learned why Boone and Shannon have different last names, I had looked at the cast at IMDB and this was very puzzling.)
I think I get the dog hint now. That’s pretty interesting.
I love Sawyer’s nicknames, they really crack me up.
I really want to know what the deal is with Hurley. I haven’t learned his story yet and he seems to be the guy that talks to everyone.
I think I get the dog hint now. That’s pretty interesting.
I love Sawyer’s nicknames, they really crack me up.
I really want to know what the deal is with Hurley. I haven’t learned his story yet and he seems to be the guy that talks to everyone.
Hurley's episode in the season 1 is probably my favorite all-time. Well, at least if in the top 3.
Joe
Joe
Damn, I can't wait. I don't know how you guys make it through the commercial breaks, much less the entire week. I just had to wait 4 days for my next 4 episodes of Lost and I was having withdrawals. I was actually starting to dream about it.
Similar threads
