Should Ayton be Traded?

Should the Suns trade Ayton?

  • Yes, trade him ASAP

  • Maybe, depends on who is hired as coach

  • No, let's see what he can do without Monty


Results are only viewable after voting.

Ouchie-Z-Clown

I'm better than Mulli!
Joined
Sep 16, 2002
Posts
63,615
Reaction score
58,062
Location
SoCal
Ayton was ranked #14 by Bleacher Report's best bigs for the 23-24 season preview. Perhaps lower than some would like. I think that's fair considering it's not just Centers listed and overall impact is taken into account.

He ranked #54 overall in their top 100.



Top 100
Hard to argue him over any of them. Maybe draymond, but tough to argue Ayton contributes to winning more than draymond.
 

Ouchie-Z-Clown

I'm better than Mulli!
Joined
Sep 16, 2002
Posts
63,615
Reaction score
58,062
Location
SoCal
Ayton was ranked #14 by Bleacher Report's best bigs for the 23-24 season preview. Perhaps lower than some would like. I think that's fair considering it's not just Centers listed and overall impact is taken into account.

He ranked #54 overall in their top 100.



Top 100
8 KD
9 book
34 beal
54 ayton

Not bad
 

AzStevenCal

ASFN IDOL
Supporting Member
Joined
Apr 2, 2004
Posts
36,760
Reaction score
16,531
He's big. He's healthy. He's young. HE DOES NOT HAVE A POSITIVE ATTITUDE

Sure, he'll get you 18 and 10, but not on the nights that matter. Not in the series that matter. Because that's when his positive attitude gives way to the incredible shrinking man - with symptoms including deafness and the inability to speak

When they rank him at #14 it isn't a testament to his basketball skills or positive attitude - it's an indictment of the current talent pool in the NBA as far as bigs go

I'm still trying to chill on the Ayton bashing but it's hard when the conversations are so cyclical - lest we forget what happens in the playoffs every year - Ayton is more of a burden than a viable big
I said he "appears" to have a positive attitude. I'm not in the huddle, on the bench or in the locker room so I can't go any further than that.

And when you say "lest we forget what happens in the playoffs every year", perhaps you should heed that reminder. Like most of the team he's been disappointing the past two playoffs but he was dominant often during our earlier run to the finals and all told was probably our best player behind Booker that postseason.
 

BirdGangThing

Cultist
Joined
Dec 27, 2019
Posts
15,855
Reaction score
21,706
Location
Arcadia
I said he "appears" to have a positive attitude. I'm not in the huddle, on the bench or in the locker room so I can't go any further than that.

And when you say "lest we forget what happens in the playoffs every year", perhaps you should heed that reminder. Like most of the team he's been disappointing the past two playoffs but he was dominant often during our earlier run to the finals and all told was probably our best player behind Booker that postseason.
I think Ayton was the catalyst for our playoff let downs - I think his mental attitude was the precursor for the whole team(s) falling apart. I don't think he's learned anything between then and now. And as far as this domination you speak of, it tended (past tense ) to happen when the team was already playing well - because that's when he plays well - when there's no pressure - because he disappears during clutch time
 

AzStevenCal

ASFN IDOL
Supporting Member
Joined
Apr 2, 2004
Posts
36,760
Reaction score
16,531
I think Ayton was the catalyst for our playoff let downs - I think his mental attitude was the precursor for the whole team(s) falling apart. I don't think he's learned anything between then and now. And as far as this domination you speak of, it tended (past tense ) to happen when the team was already playing well - because that's when he plays well - when there's no pressure - because he disappears during clutch time
I don't think he's particularly strong willed (hard headed maybe) but I also don't agree with you painting him the way you have. He often set the tone for the team early and we played well as a result of his play. Then, for whatever reason, he'd stop being a factor and we'd play poorly. He isn't the guy I'd want to take the last second clutch shot but I've seen nothing to indicate he's at the opposite end of clutch as you suggest.

And no way in the world would I single him out for our playoff disappointments. I find it almost laughable to suggest that he was the catalyst for the final results. He failed to lift us up, so did every other player on the roster not to mention the coaching crew.

I just don't get the over-the-top hate on DA. I understand anyone being disappointed in him or frustrated by him. I even understand some of you being so highly motivated to ship his butt out of town. But this idea that he was horrible or the reason we failed to win a championship or failed to advance against lesser squads is just unreasonable IMO.
 

95pro

ASFN Icon
Joined
May 10, 2007
Posts
12,682
Reaction score
4,158
I think Ayton was the catalyst for our playoff let downs - I think his mental attitude was the precursor for the whole team(s) falling apart. I don't think he's learned anything between then and now. And as far as this domination you speak of, it tended (past tense ) to happen when the team was already playing well - because that's when he plays well - when there's no pressure - because he disappears during clutch time

I think the real catalysts were Monty and CP3, and its been talked about and backed up by players and inside sources from the Suns and previous teams. How DA dealt with that was not ideal for sure. Clutch time is reserved for stars like Book and KD.
 

BirdGangThing

Cultist
Joined
Dec 27, 2019
Posts
15,855
Reaction score
21,706
Location
Arcadia
Ayton did the whole choke and disappear during the playoffs again, just this past May, in the playoffs - when it mattered most - and he was outplayed by Jock freakin Landale

Now he's knocking up porn stars and taking pot shots at his teammates but sure... he's magically going to do a mental 180 because Vogel can turn water into wine
 
Last edited:

AzStevenCal

ASFN IDOL
Supporting Member
Joined
Apr 2, 2004
Posts
36,760
Reaction score
16,531
Ayton did the whole choke and disappear during the playoffs again, just this past May, in the playoffs - when it mattered most - and he was outplayed by Jock freakin Landale

Now he's knocking up porn stars and taking pot shots at his teammates but sure... he's magically going to do a mental 180 because Vogel can turn water into wine

Do they have the free continental breakfast in fantasy land? What time is check out?
Weak. Very weak. You're in the DA is horrible camp and that's fine but that doesn't mean the rest of us are in the DA is great camp. The vast majority of us here have real problems with DA.
 

Covert Rain

Father smelt of elderberries!
Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Posts
36,519
Reaction score
15,604
Location
Arizona
Ayton did the whole choke and disappear during the playoffs again, just this past May, in the playoffs - when it mattered most - and he was outplayed by Jock freakin Landale

Now he's knocking up porn stars and taking pot shots at his teammates but sure... he's magically going to do a mental 180 because Vogel can turn water into wine

Do they have the free continental breakfast in fantasy land? What time is check out?
Who here actually believes he is going to do a complete 180? Sounds like you are manipulating what people think to make a point. The vast majority of people here want to be optimistic but most are skeptical he is going to be a changed player. Most of us just hope we see an improvement and a bit more consistency.
 

BirdGangThing

Cultist
Joined
Dec 27, 2019
Posts
15,855
Reaction score
21,706
Location
Arcadia
Weak. Very weak. You're in the DA is horrible camp and that's fine but that doesn't mean the rest of us are in the DA is great camp. The vast majority of us here have real problems with DA.
What's weak is not getting rid of Ayton before this year's playoffs - I don't really want to waste one of the few BBD years we'll have only to find out Ayton is who we thought he was
 

AzStevenCal

ASFN IDOL
Supporting Member
Joined
Apr 2, 2004
Posts
36,760
Reaction score
16,531
What's weak is not getting rid of Ayton before this year's playoffs - I don't really want to waste one of the few BBD years we'll have only to find out Ayton is who we thought he was
Nice job of sidestepping - you'd be all over you if you'd done that to yourself in a conversation here.

But ignoring that, I disagree that it's simply "weak". If we had a chance to get value for him and didn't take it, I could see making the case that it was weak. But you routinely present this situation as one where we'd simply be better offer without him even if we got nothing in return and had to eat his contract I I think that's further away from reality than many of DA's comments.
 

BirdGangThing

Cultist
Joined
Dec 27, 2019
Posts
15,855
Reaction score
21,706
Location
Arcadia
Nice job of sidestepping - you'd be all over you if you'd done that to yourself in a conversation here.

But ignoring that, I disagree that it's simply "weak". If we had a chance to get value for him and didn't take it, I could see making the case that it was weak. But you routinely present this situation as one where we'd simply be better offer without him even if we got nothing in return and had to eat his contract I I think that's further away from reality than many of DA's comments.
Just stop with the "nothing in return" retort, it's already been gone through ad nauseam. You can't have a coward on your starting 5 and still compete with a legit starting 5. That's it.
 

Covert Rain

Father smelt of elderberries!
Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Posts
36,519
Reaction score
15,604
Location
Arizona
Just stop with the "nothing in return" retort, it's already been gone through ad nauseam. You can't have a coward on your starting 5 and still compete with a legit starting 5. That's it.
You can't jettison a player who other teams showed interest in like Indiana for example and simply say we should get rid of him even if it means getting nothing. You can't jettison a player that has a valuable expiring contract. That's just stupid. That's not a retort. That's letting blind hatred dictate a stupid decision. That's it.
 

Mainstreet

Cruisin' Mainstreet
Supporting Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2003
Posts
118,165
Reaction score
58,453
Just stop with the "nothing in return" retort, it's already been gone through ad nauseam. You can't have a coward on your starting 5 and still compete with a legit starting 5. That's it.

If you explained how the Suns get rid of Ayton's $100+ million contract, it would help.

The Suns may be beyond the timeline to use the waive and stretch provision.

Many would agree Ayton would have been better off traded if there was a reasonable alternative.

Now the best option may be to see how he plays under Frank Vogel. Hopefully his play on Team Bahama has a carryover effect.
 
Last edited:

Chaplin

Better off silent
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
46,420
Reaction score
16,937
Location
Round Rock, TX
Waiving and stretching Deandre Ayton would be the stupidest idea in the history of stupid ideas.

If we want to talk about fantastical implausibilities, let's talk about the Bucks waiving Giannis and us signing him for the minimum. Has as much chance of happening.
 

BirdGangThing

Cultist
Joined
Dec 27, 2019
Posts
15,855
Reaction score
21,706
Location
Arcadia
If you explained how the Suns get rid of Ayton's $100+ million contract, it would help.
I've already done this. I saw a sign and trade being the most viable - but thing is nobody wanted/wants Ayton with his contract - otherwise he'd be gone because we most definitely tried

How many years are we realistically expecting/hoping BBD to play together? 2 or 3? And that's hoping none of the trio are injured?

With everything we've put into this self created all or nothing scenario.. we don't have time to see if Ayton eventually pans out or finishes puberty
 

Mainstreet

Cruisin' Mainstreet
Supporting Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2003
Posts
118,165
Reaction score
58,453
I've already done this. I saw a sign and trade being the most viable - but thing is nobody wanted/wants Ayton with his contract - otherwise he'd be gone because we most definitely tried

How many years are we realistically expecting/hoping BBD to play together? 2 or 3? And that's hoping none of the trio are injured?

With everything we've put into this self created all or nothing scenario.. we don't have time to see if Ayton eventually pans out or finishes puberty

It takes two to party. What was the sign and trade option that was on the table?
 

elindholm

edited for content
Joined
Sep 14, 2002
Posts
27,495
Reaction score
9,715
Location
L.A. area
Great.. DA knocking up porn stars..

His genes be propagAyton.
 
Top